Change Is Hard

…but change is certain.

Is what's good for the economy good for me?

9 Comments

I’ve never been a Black Friday shopper.  Maybe because I generally worked the Friday after Thanksgiving.  And if I wasn’t at work I was down South with family.  Even then we didn’t go shopping.  I can’t figure out what the draw is – I’ve never felt the urge to get up in the middle of the night after a day of overeating,  stand in a line in the dark and cold, just to get a questionably good deal on anything.  But apparently a lot of people do this.

So this year I was surprised when I caught a bit of the excitement myself.  Newscasters everywhere were talking about retailers making sales goals by mid-morning or early afternoon.  There were excited interviews with store owners and managers talking about the crowds being bigger, the sales higher than last year.  Everyone was all smiles.

Here in Michigan the recession started earlier and will last longer than for most of the rest of the country.  That’s the price we pay for being an industrial manufacturing state.   So I am excited that people are spending and sales are up and money is flowing and spirits are rising.

Still.

How much stuff do we need?  Really?  What exactly is so important that you’d get up at 4 a.m. to shop at WalMart?  Or worse – give up family time on Thanksgiving to go to the mall?  And what about those people that have to work Black Friday or Thanksgiving Day so that we can add some more stuff to our stuff-filled homes?  Wouldn’t the world be a better place – calmer, happier, healthier – if everyone stayed home and spent that maniacal shopping time with their families?

I’ve always said that everything should be closed on Thanksgiving.  Especially grocery stores.  I know that having the local grocery open on Thanksgiving is a wonderful thing for those of us not organized enough to make sure we have everything we need to make a fabulous meal.  But truly, if you forgot to buy the cranberries and it’s Thanksgiving morning it’s better for your family to eat something else than to make some poor cashier hang around at work just to save your dinner menu.

If I were Queen of the world we’d all get a 4 day weekend at Thanksgiving.  But only if everyone pledged to spend them at home being thankful for the people and stuff they already have.  Because more stuff isn’t going to make any of us any happier.

Unless, of course, you’re going to purchase the stuff from a manufacturer based in Michigan.

Author: dawnkinster

I'm a long time banker having worked in banks since the age of 17. I took a break when I turned 50 and went back to school. I graduated right when the economy took a turn for the worst and after a year of library work found myself unemployed. I was lucky that my previous bank employer wanted me back. So here I am again, a long time banker. Change is hard.

9 thoughts on “Is what's good for the economy good for me?

  1. Lots to think about here, Dawn. I never leave the house on Thanksgiving, so I don’t know if NJ’s in Lake Leelanau was open that morning, as usual. Thanksgiving and Christmas mornings, until noon–that was their custom, and many the husband and/or father who found a need to drive to Lake Leelanau on a holiday morning for something the family just “had” to have! More likely, a bit of normality to counter the holiday buzz at home?

    Friday after Thanksgiving in Northport is usually dead as a doornail, with all the locals rushing off to Traverse City for big store shopping, so I planned ahead to decorate my shop tree that day and enjoyed stringing lights and listening to the radio, but I didn’t mind at all, either, when a man from St. Louis, Missouri, on his first trip ever to Leelanau County, found Dog Ears Books and filled two boxes with treasures. Then Saturday was Open House day for businesses in Northport, with a Story Hour for little kids at my bookstore. The little ones are so cute! I had chairs for grownups and a big blanket and comforter on the floor for the kids, and as I read the stories they kept creeping closer and closer to me until they were practically sitting in my lap. That made being at “work” very worthwhile.

    But now it’s Sunday of the holiday weekend, and I am enjoying my day off to the max!

    Like

  2. Before it was known as Black Friday, I knew a woman that always took that day off work and did her Christmas shopping. I never have, and I never will. But then again, our Christmas giving has reduced so much, I have no need to battle the crowds. One of the reasons we moved to Oregon was to escape the Southern California crowds. Most of my shopping this year (and it’s all very basic) has been done online. What’s left will be done online. It’s more important to me to spend these days at home where it’s warm and quiet and my loves are.

    Like

  3. Christmas is so commercialized it makes me sad. I hate hearing Christmas music in the stores in October. I said to Jeff on our way to Thanksgiving dinner….”Would our country always be in the red if everyone stopped giving gifts on Christmas or would we spend our money some other way?”

    Jeff said, “Our country would fall apart if we didn’t all go into credit card debit every January.”

    Sad,but probably true to some extent.

    I do all my shopping online, with my dogs at my side!

    Like

  4. I never shop on Black Friday either! But if it would benefit the state MI then maybe I would! 🙂

    Like

  5. You’re right of course.
    It’s christmas day that the big celebration over here in england.
    Everything is closed, except for some asian owned shops.
    But some of thwm dont actually celebrate christmas in which case, why would they close.
    Thanksgiving and christmas should always be spent with family.
    Shame, i will have to work christmas day. lol

    Like

  6. We don’t have any Black Friday here but we also have all sorts of retail discounts or year end sales in the name of festive celebrations. I also feel that we have far too many festive seasons here as it’s a multi-racial country. Since August, we celebrated Chinese Mooncake (Mid-Autumn) Festival, then we had Muslim New Year in September which stretched to October, a large number of people here also have a fair share of Halloween, and we had Deepavali for our Indian friends in November and now, Christmas Carols are played in all the malls. I can tell you straight after Christmas, people will start to prepare another party for New Year. Mind you, Chinese New Year falls in February… There are something else in March and April and May… Oh Gosh!!!

    Is this recession time? I deeply doubt! People say their business isn’t good but look at the crowds in the malls!

    I don’t understand it!

    Like

  7. Okay, I’m back. First of all, I hate the term “Black Friday.” Doesn’t it sound ominous? Like the anniversary of a gangster shoot-out or a stock market crash? What a horrible name!

    As a small town retailer, however, I have to say something about what strikes me as a false dilemma. The choices are not: go to giant big box stores at 6 a.m. or don’t shop; or go to giant big box stores at 6 a.m. and stand in line an hour or do all your shopping online. There are still small, friendly, personal shops in this country, and I know that because mine is one of them. I don’t open at 6 a.m., and the only time there’s a line at the counter is for a big book signing, i.e., once or twice a year.

    Not to be crassly commercial here, but as a retailer I’m proud of what I sell: BOOKS! They are not made of plastic! They require no batteries! They’re not junk that will stop working sometime in January and end up in a landfill! I tell you, the more I see of shoddy, unnecessary merchandise, the prouder I am to be a bookseller. Now I know that a lot of your readers, Dawn, are buying books online, but I feel strongly that REAL bookstores are important to communities, and I would urge your readers to remember to visit them on a year-round basis!

    Thanks for letting me sound off.

    Like

  8. I was so sad when I heard commercials about shopping on Thanksgiving Day. I like the idea of getting 4 days off as long as we all promise not to shop!

    Like

  9. I agree with everyone! Especially about shopping at our small town locally owned shops. And if I had one of those around here that’s where I’d be. As it is though, I’ll be staying in on the Friday after Thanksgiving…or I’ll be at work. Or…just maybe I should scout around and see what local shops there are that I just haven’t taken time to notice! Now THAT would be fun!

    Like

Leave a reply to Arts Web Show Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.