Change Is Hard

…but change is certain.

How much is YOUR library worth to you?

38 Comments

Tonight’s local news aired a piece about property taxes, specifically one woman’s fight to eliminate the only tax, she says, that risks a person’s home if left unpaid. She said that people who can’t pay for food or utilities have to pay their property taxes or risk their home.

She concedes that some things property taxes pay for, like police and fire, are necessary so she’s fine if money for those are collected, but she specifically seems to be angry about paying for a library, which she says she never uses.

When I moved to my little town in 1992 the library here was housed in a historic one room school building, and had been since 1976, with books crowded onto shelves and piled on windowsills. It was a tiny space but it was a library and I was grateful it was there. In 1998 the community approved a .41 millage to build a township building to hold offices and the library. The new library opened in 2002 and operated on that .41 millage until just a year or so ago when we approved an additional .5 millage in support of the library.

I’m pretty proud of our community for passing those millage requests the first time they were put on the ballot.

According to information online the Springfield Township Library serves a community of 14,000 people, has a collection of over 70,000 items and has public internet computers, wi-fi, meeting rooms, interlibrary loan, adult, teen and children’s programming.

Our township offices including the library, built to blend into the landscape.

I know this is true because I’ve used nearly all of it. And every time I visit the beautiful building with it’s big windows looking out over parkland I’m grateful all over again for our local library.

Still, one part of my brain understands where the woman is coming from. She never uses her library, yet she pays for it. I’ve been thinking about that since the news aired.

So…I wonder…what do you think about being forced to pay for something you don’t use? Should there be a use tax instead? Or some other way to fund things like libraries?

The parkland adjacent to the library includes Katie’s park.

On one hand I get not wanting to pay for something I don’t use. On the other hand…I hope I never have to use the fire department…but I’m still willing to pay for it. And wasn’t there a time, back in the Ben Franklin days, when people paid a fee to have fire department service, and if your house was on fire but you hadn’t paid the fee they let it burn?

Is that the way we want to live now? How much is your library worth to you?

Interesting question.

PS: If you’ve read this far, go read this post, written almost 15 years ago about one night I worked at a public library. Made me smile in remembrance.

Author: dawnkinster

I'm a long time banker having worked in banks since the age of 17. I took a break when I turned 50 and went back to school. I graduated right when the economy took a turn for the worst and after a year of library work found myself unemployed. I was lucky that my previous bank employer wanted me back. So here I am again, a long time banker. Change is hard.

38 thoughts on “How much is YOUR library worth to you?

  1. That is a tough one. I can understand the frustration of paying high taxes when you have trouble buying groceries. You want to know where your money is going and doesn’t it fall in line with paying school taxes even if you don’t have kids (or they are out of school)?

    Like

  2. If that chick isn’t taking advantage of the many services and programs that her library provides, that’s her loss. There’s no reason that a fee for library users should be considered. Low income and impoverished people need those services and often use them to give themselves a leg up. Their lives improve and they contribute more to the common good.Long live libraries!

    Like

  3. Since NH doesn’t have an income or sales tax, we have one of the highest property taxes in the country. Most goes to the schools – truthfully, I think an income tax is fairer, but… Anyway, I don’t have kids but I happily pay the tax because I don’t want to live with in a town with a bunch of ignorant people. lol. Actually, I highly value education and wish we could spend 10 times the amount on education than defense. I feel the same way about libraries – they play a super important role in society. Don’t use it? It is free to use, so that says a lot more about you than about the library! If you can’t afford a house, which means all of it including taxes, rent. There is no shame in renting.

    Yep, I have zero sympathy for that woman 😉

    Like

    • I agree. She has no clue the value of the library in her community. Maybe she SHOULD visit it so she could learn something. This is an argument libraries have faced on and off for years. They’ve also been told they are irrelevant now that ‘everyone has the internet.’ Which of course is not true on so many levels.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Libraries provide entertainment sure enough, but they also provide information, education, legal information, home construction/improvement information, safety information, air quality information, travel information, medical information, photo books for those who cannot read, audio books for those who cannot read (or hold a book), books for children when they aren’t in school, books for young adults when they aren’t in school. The library I worked for provided a summer reading program for kids in Washington State when their local school didn’t do that. There is also a “library for the blind” in every state in the USA, for people who are blind, for people who are visually impaired, for people who don’t have arms and can’t hold a book from that or just from arthritis (tho they may have 20-20 vision), audio books for people who are dyslexic or have a roaming eye, there are audio books and braille books for people who hold jobs, attorneys, doctors, architects, and for people who are just “just” living at home as best they can. Libraries are life savers! They entertain, sure enough, but they also educate and save lives and provide unequaled support and education and help to all citizens in every community in this country. Paying taxes for libraries is the same as supporting our schools. Even if YOU don’t have kids, that money goes to create a better economy, a better future, and a better environment for everyone, kids and adults.

    Most libraries will also help you connect with your state legislature reps, and other government agencies for anything at all that you need.

    And they have books about doggies … and camping … and barns … and trees.

    I love libraries. :-)

    Like

    • I love libraries too. When I was fed up with my corporate banking job, stressed and grieving my parents back in 2005 I went to my local library to think about what I’d rather do if I could. Sitting there I realized that what I’d love to do was work in a library. Then I found out you had to have a masters to do that, so I went back to grad school in 2006, graduated in 2008, got a job in 2009….when the economy tanked, got layed off at the end of 2009 along with most everyone else working in the library and that was the end of that dream.

      Like

  5. It’s difficult for me to comment on this as being in Australia, our tax system pretty much pays for everything that is in the public sector. Public libraries are included. But if I imagine how I would feel about paying for a facility that I didn’t use, if it was of benefit to others in my local community, I would not begrudge paying.
    I read your old post too, and see why it made you smile when reading it again. That was such a sweet gesture of the older lady.

    Like

    • Yes it was sweet. There were lots of sweet things I got to observe during the 10 months I got to work in a library. Got to observe some not so sweet things too, but mostly it was a good experience. I wouldn’t have left but the economy turned down and everyone lost their jobs.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. I sympathize with those who struggle to pay properly taxes. Yet, the notion of wanting taxes to only go to services that one uses is a crabbed and selfish notion, all too common nowadays

    Like

  7. I doubt that anyone loves to pay taxes but it kind of what makes things work, right? Libraries are so important but so are all the other services that are covered by taxes. I think they are necessary!

    Like

    • Right. And I feel so lucky to have what I have, to have had the advantage of a good education and a family with some assets, that I don’t begrudge paying for stuff I don’t use if it’s for the betterment of our community.

      Like

  8. I think the biggest problem is when politician & bureaucrats squander the tax dollars (at all levels of government). I may not like paying taxes, but I approve and appreciate all the things they provide. It is the blatant disregard for fiscal responsibility that gets me going. Here in Canada we are being taxed to death; many can no longer afford heat or food, let alone their property taxes. I love the library, but our local library is designating the buildings for meetings and sanctuary spaces (?), and there are less and less physical books, and now even less e-books as well!

    Like

    • That sounds complicated. I know when I went back to grad school to become a librarian, I was looking for some material in the grad library and the first time I was there I couldn’t find the books! :) 🙂 :) It was all computer stations. Turns out the ‘stacks’ were in another section of the building. 

      Liked by 1 person

  9. Don’t want to judge, but would like to sit down with her and look at her budget. Is she paying monthly for cable TV? Netflix? Unlimited data on her phone? What about internet? Could she get all she needed or wanted from these subscriptions, from her local library?

    Like

    • People could definitely get a lot (but not all) of those things ‘free’ from the library. The thing is they don’t want to. They want it all in the comfort of their home. I, on the other hand, love to go to the library and just sit and read magazines, because I gave up all my subscriptions when we were both unemployed and I never started any of them up again.

      Like

  10. Great question, Dawn – Our local library is the hub of our community and offers much more than just book lending. There are many things that we do not use in our community but pay for through our taxes, etc. I am totally fine with that as the focus is community!

    Like

  11. That argument – “I don’t use it, so why should I pay for it?” – applies to a few things, including schools, as mentioned in another comment or two. But – all of us are affected by lack of knowledge or education, and both schools and libraries are necessary for those. I get the argument, but I think we need to think beyond ourselves and more about the community, the county, the state, the country – and what forms our leaders. . .

    Like

  12. I took the SMART bus from Lincoln Park to Downtown Detroit for many years, starting in 1976 when I took it, then connected to get on a Detroit bus to the campus at Wayne State University. Thereafter I took the bus more decades to Downtown Detroit to work until working from home in 2011. It just grinds me when people don’t want to pay for the bus service just because they don’t use it. For me, the bus was convenient, dropping me off in front of my office building and I didn’t have to deal with traffic either. Many people prefer the bus to a car.

    Like

    • When I went back to grad school at age 50 in Ann Arbor I parked outside the city and took the bus into campus because I HATE driving in AA. I loved riding the city bus. I wish my area had public transportation, I’d use it and be more than willing to pay for it. Public transportation moves people more efficiently, causes less congestion, less parking lots need to be built, it’s an improvement for the whole community and as such should be supported by the whole community in the form of taxes to pay for it.

      Liked by 1 person

      • I was an avid reader while taking the bus, especially when I was a student … less studying time at night. I hope libraries are around for a long time. They have e-books available for those who are not keen on reading a regular book.

        Like

  13. Great points for us to ponder. Our library collects donated books each year then they have a huge sale of those books as a fund-raiser. It’s a win-win for the community. Taxes are always a touchy subject. 😆

    Like

    • Taxes are tough. But I think most people use services they take for granted that are paid for or at least subsidized by taxes. Our library does the same. Somehow I always have a box or two or three of books to donate. I don’t know where they all come from!

      Liked by 1 person

  14. Well, we all pay taxes on stuff we use. I’ve paid school taxes for years, but never sent a child to one. But I don’t mind paying since having a good school system helps your overall property value (plus it pays a teacher’s salary😉). I pay for sewer service even though I have no way to access the sewer system from my house. It is what it is.

    I just checked the library portion of my tax bill – $32 a year. Wow, what a bargain! That’s less than it would cost to buy two books. 

    I think the woman needs to visit her library and see all the cool stuff it has to offer. Mine even has free passes to a variety of museums and historical sites! 

    Like

    • I bet she’s never been in her library. $32 a year, huh? That IS a bargain! I wonder what ours is. Whatever it is I believe I’m lucky to have the beautiful library in my township! When I worked at a library system in the next county north of here we had those passes too. Hardly anyone ever used them. I wonder if they still offer them? Did you ever use one?

      Like

  15. I never have used one! I always forget about them until I arrive at the place and have to pay. LOL.

    I remember reading your posts about your time working at the library. I loved how you encountered such a variety of people.

    Liked by 1 person

  16. I don’t think this is tough at all. As a reader (and a writer), I’m a huge proponent of libraries. Just because you don’t use something doesn’t mean you shouldn’t have to help pay for it. What about public schools? I no longer have kiddos attending school here, but I’m still taxed for them. And how about lakes? You won’t catch me swimming in one, but I’m all for keeping them and paying for them.

    Our public library came into being with money from Andrew Carnegie, a big believer in the need for individuals to educate themselves. I can’t fathom living in a town without a public library, with its vast store of knowledge, research materials, videos for rent, computers, and so forth!

    Like

Leave a reply to Linda Allen Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.