Change Is Hard

…but change is certain.

Brain v.s. AI

14 Comments

Lately, not often, but once in awhile, I notice something in my periphery vision that looks like a person standing off in the distance. Down the road, across the lawn, far away. It’s just a moment, mostly a dark grey shadow, and when I look directly there’s nothing there. Once in awhile there’s a small tree or a mailbox but lots of times there’s nothing there at all.

I brought it up with my nurse practicioner at my annual physical and she asked me if I had told my ophthalmologist. I hadn’t but I had an appointment coming up, so I said I would. Today I sat in the chair with my eyes dialated and told him the story.

He started smiling and said he usually sees this in 90 year old people. And that it’s just my brain that sees something and fills in the rest to create, for a moment, something that makes sense. I had thought that was what was going on myself, so was relieved when he looked in my eyes and didn’t see anything to worry about.

But the whole experience reminded me of something that happened when I was processing photos from my night under the stars with a friend and her daughter. I processed one photo where the daughter’s phone was shining down near the bottom of the frame. I had been shooting the stars above her, but sometimes she ended up in the image.

On this particular photo, one of the first I worked on, I thought it was just her phone that was glowing. I used the ‘remove’ button in Lightroom to get rid of that glowing shape. I had never used that function before. I edited the rest of the image, knowing the whole bottom 1/3 of the picture was dark beach.

Turns out it was her face that was lit up, and when I erased her face I left the rest of her body intact. That is, if you read the instructions on how to use this button, a problem.

Witout knowing any of this I thought maybe I’d lighten up the dark beach just a touch and see how that looked beneath the Milky Way. And I got this:

Turns out I had only disappeared her face, and Lightroom, with it’s infinite AI wisdom knew there couldn’t be a person with no face, so it created one for me. If you look carefully you’ll see a guy sitting in a chair. The chair that was right there with us all night.

I actually thought for a couple minutes that some guy had joined us for the night of star gazing, even though I knew there was no guy there. And then I shared the new image with my friend and her daughter and they freaked out too.

No, no guy quietly came and sat in our chair. It’s just that AI completed the person I had left in the image. Just like my brain completes the image it thinks it sees out of the side of my eye.

No wonder it’s hard to know what the truth is anymore.

Author: dawnkinster

I'm a long time banker having worked in banks since the age of 17. I took a break when I turned 50 and went back to school. I graduated right when the economy took a turn for the worst and after a year of library work found myself unemployed. I was lucky that my previous bank employer wanted me back. So here I am again, a long time banker. Change is hard.

14 thoughts on “Brain v.s. AI

  1. There goes the old saying “pictures don’t lie.”

    Like

  2. Wow, things are getting curiouser and curiouser… 🤔🫤

    Like

  3. Well, this was most interesting. A little creepy, a little funny, but still very interesting.

    Like

  4. wow!

    Like

  5. That is crazy! I would have been freaked out, too!!

    Like

  6. Do not trust “AI”. “AI” (artificial intelligence) is just computer language written by humans, it’s not intelligent. It’s just computer language/program written by thousands of different humans in hundreds of thousands of different programs all around the world, written differently by each of them, that change online digital reality. I’m a retired Microsoft Certified Systems Engineer. I hate AI! This isn’t curious and it isn’t funny. All manner of computer/digital programs are using the “excuse” of using “AI” when it’s just their human programmers that are changing what you see to benefit them. Honestly, there is no “intelligence” about it. It’s just manipulation. Some day there might be a true artificial intelligence … today there is shit stupid and manipulative “intelligence”. Microsoft might remove my MCSE license for saying this, but it’s true. We really are being manipulated just by humans who want to benefit from our naivete.

    Like

  7. I found this very disconcerting. And creepy. There is a lot posted on social media that is AI generated, but we are led to believe is real.

    Like

  8. AI is creepy. Coincidentally, I had a conversation with my computer engineer daughter about this last night when we went out to dinner. She echoed much of what Ann Hay commented above, and said to remove any Microsoft AI apps from a computer if you use them, because in the name of “teaching” AI, the programs “scrape” your personal work for its own “learning”. I use a Chromebook and am considering shutting down Gemini even though I don’t use it. I have had the same creepy experience in Lightroom when I tried to remove a human from a shot of Niagara Falls – it replaced the spot with a different human! I found out that if you don’t make your spot that you want to erase “human shaped”, make it more of a blob, it won’t put another random human in your photo!

    Like

    • Thanks Karma. Indeed, “AI” is not intelligent. It is a group of thousands of computer programs written by tens of thousands of humans, and each program is different from the other. A VERY few are ok, most are really bizarre and manipulative, most are manipulative and aren’t trustworthy and most are meant to take what you write and upload it to the folks who want to know what you write for whatever their purposes are. Do not trust “AI” and don’t let it on your computer or laptop or tablet or phone.

      Like

  9. That is wild! I rarely use the remove feature in Photoshop or Adobe Express…. but I can see this happening. I have noticed when upload something to Instagram it asks me if it has been modified with AI. Interesting.

    Like

  10. I think the more AI sneaks into our lives without our asking it to, the more freaked out we are going to get. I’d rather AI get my permission each time he/she/it wants in.

    Like

  11. This is fascinating, but in a creepy way. I’m still on the fence about AI. Yes, I worked in tech for years, but that was before all this AI-stuff became as prominent as it is now. It sort of feels like it can be manipulated by whoever’s in charge to say whatever they want said, fact or not. And I worry about a world where people could be replaced by machines. Despite the reports, I don’t think the jobs market is anywhere near as rosy as they say. It’s good to hear there’s nothing wrong with your vision though!

    Like

  12. That is eerie – AI is too smart for its own good sometimes, like the predictive text here on WordPress. As I am typing my comment, AI presumes what I want to say and lays it all out there, should I not want to use my own words. But I like my own words! My long posts I write in Word when I return from a long walk, just a draft and I finalize it when I see the photos. Then AI is overly helpful, suggesting where to be concise or plunk in a comma … I never use a comma before the word “and”, so I tell it to “ignore always” but a few paragraphs later, there it is, bossy as ever. Grrr!

    Like

  13. Oh boy – that’s creepy!

    My dad just spent a few nights in the hospital (he’s ok), and he had a “virtual nurse” on the TV screen in his room. She actually started the conversation with “I am not AI”. But for how much longer?

    Like

Leave a reply to Denise Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.