Change Is Hard

…but change is certain.

When the music stopped

45 Comments

I don’t remember when I started playing with the local community band. And when I joined I certainly didn’t expect to still be playing years (maybe more than15 years!) later or how lucky I’d be to form a friendship with the band’s music director.

But it was easy, she was a clarinet player as well as a band director in the public schools. We were similar ages, and had lots of the same interests. She gave me tickets to the Detroit Symphony, took me and others to the Detroit Institute of Art to see the Van Gogh show, invited me over to play with her beloved kitties, made meals for my husband and me when we got Covid the first time.

She gave of herself in ways too numerous to mention. As she did with so many others.

In recent years Shelley has fought cancer, going to treatments and tests but still coming, every Tuesday night, to rehearse a band that on it’s best days can be a handful. We are something of an island for misfit musicians, all with different sets of skills, different levels of commitment, but each of us 100% lovers of making music. When we get it right it is so right, and when we fail, well, we fail spectacularly.

And still she came, every Tuesday night. Arriving early, she was the last one to leave.

At our October concert, “Three Women and a Podium”

When the cancer struck again it became harder for her. She had moved an hour away to be closer to family and her doctors. The trip back to be with us was sometimes long, sometimes impossible. Still, she persisted. When necessary other dedicated music directors stepped in to give her a break.

But we always knew she’d be back. She wasn’t ready to give up her community band.

The last concert she conducted for us was this past October. By Christmas she didn’t have enough stamina to stand on the podium and keep us in line. I texted her after the Christmas concert, her favorite of each year, and gave her a report. We had done well, had a good crowd, we missed her, Santa said hello. She told me she was grieving the loss and missed us too.

She never came back.

Last week at rehearsal we learned she was in hospice at the family’s home. She was receiving visitors and cards and spending time with her grandchildren. This past Tuesday morning she died, her family surrounding her, and music playing.

Of course it was a Tuesday.

In Michigan’s UP on a 3 day trip, where it rained every single day.

Maybe she knew that we’d need each other, as one by one we heard the news. She knew, of course, that there is no better group of people to be with when you’re mourning your music director than the people with whom you share the music.

And so we went to rehearsal. Those of us that knew had a hard time walking into the building, into the band room, looking at the podium. Even though she hadn’t been physically there since last fall, it was still her podium. Those that hadn’t heard the news yet sat in stunned silence as it was announced.

The room was quiet for a moment and then people started sharing stories and we laughed a bit and teared up a bit. And then we did the best thing we could do for ourselves, and for her.

We made music. For a moment the music had stopped. But only for a moment.

Last week I wrote Shelley a letter, thanking her for being a friend, for her advice, for her musical support, for our travels together, for her generosity, for her time and her care. There are so many stories I could tell you about her, and I am just one of hundreds who have stories of her giving to them and their families.

I ended my letter to her by reminding her of the hundreds of students she had mentored over her 30+ years of teaching music in our public schools. Her legacy will go on forever through those students, many who have made sharing music their careers.

I told her she was the stone tossed into quiet water and the ripples she made are still spreading out into the universe. I told her I didn’t think any of us could have a bigger affect on the world than what she’d done with her talent and her love.

A subset of us, playing a pop-up concert during Covid in her neighborhood.

And I asked her if, after she gets settled and has her celestial band warmed up and in tune, if she might look around for a way to let us know she’s OK. I told her I knew she’d be OK, but it would be nice to know.

I expect to be hit over the head with something fantastically musical any day now. And I bet that first concert up there is going to be amazing.

Author: dawnkinster

I'm a long time banker having worked in banks since the age of 17. I took a break when I turned 50 and went back to school. I graduated right when the economy took a turn for the worst and after a year of library work found myself unemployed. I was lucky that my previous bank employer wanted me back. So here I am again, a long time banker. Change is hard.

45 thoughts on “When the music stopped

  1. Dawn, this is beautiful. I got goosebumps. Hugs.

    Like

  2. I remember you trying to get me to join a community band down here, and I never put much effort into finding one. Then I was up visiting you, and Shelly came by, and together you and she, found a community band down here, and inspired me, and I joined, and had a great experience.

    Thank you Shelly. 🙂

    Like

  3. That’s exactly what she would have wanted: for the music to stop, just for a moment, and then for it to begin again.

    Like

  4. Oh gosh, Dawn. I hope Shelley is reading this. You know, after she gets that celestial band in line and in tune. This is beautiful.

    Like

  5. What a beautiful post. Thank you for sharing Shelley with us. What a lovely person she was. I am so sorry for your loss.

    Like

  6. So sorry. A member of our agility community passed at the end of the summer last year. She left two dogs who were adopted; one by family and one by friends. The older dog Dune, who was adopted by family, passed away this week. Everyone said he missed running agility with Catherine. I’m sure your friend is directing the celestial band.

    Like

  7. Oh, Dawn, that gives me shivers and tears and smiles, all at once! What a wonderful person to have had in your life. No, to HAVE in your life! That photo of her on the sandy shore, among the rocks, says a lot about her joy in life. Thank you for sharing her with us — and for sharing your love of music and your continuing life in the band.

    Like

    • She loved her life. She loved her kids and her grandkids, and I’m sure she would have loved to be here for the birth of a great grandbaby on the way. She loved her music groups and her friends and traveling and her two cats and laughing and telling stories. We will miss all of that.

      Like

  8. So very, very sorry! What a loss.

    Like

  9. This is a beautiful tribute to her. I’m so very sorry for your loss, Dawn. Hugs and love to you.

    Like

  10. Dawn, I am so sorry for the loss of your dear friend. May you find peace and comfort in precious good memories. Sending you a hug. ❤️

    Like

  11. Thank you for sharing Shelley with us. The impact she had on so many people will remain with them, and you, forever. What a gift to have known her. I am so sorry for your loss. ❤

    Like

  12. An absolutely beautiful tribute. Thank you for sharing.

    Like

  13. This is a wonderful tribute to Shelley who was someone special in your life and many other’s lives … this post made each of us feel like we knew her personally.

    Liked by 1 person

  14. What a beautiful and heartfelt tribute to Shelley. Wishing you and your fellow musicians comfort as you continue making music in her honour.

    Like

  15. I like that bit about a stone tossed into quiet waters, and how so very amazingly important music is, along with such a teacher as she was. Music in school should be a requisite along with math and english and such. It’s not an elective, it’s a priority. Thanks Dawn. Blessings on her life and heart … and on yours as well.

    Like

    • Thank you Ann. I agree, music of some type should be a requirement for every student. At least a year of something. Choir, or band or orchestra or something else the school system develops.

      Like

  16. Dawn, what a wonderful tribute to a fantastic person. As I’ve grown older, I have realized that I missed the power of music in my life the way you and many others who I come into contact with at school. The power of music bonds us in ways in which we need. I admire that you’re part of a municipal band – that’s amazing. We have one in our town and they play in the summer, and they have an amazing sound. May you be comforted by the music you made and still make. Peace.

    Like

    • I think some sort of music should be a requirement in school. Even if it’s just one semester of music appreciation, or a semester of singing in the choir…music makes a difference in the way we view the world.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Dawn, I’ve been teaching middle school 26 years. Almost everyone of the kids who were high achievers were engaged in orchestra, band or chorus. There was the occasional athlete, but that was not the norm. Somehow, someway music wires the brain for learning. I saw it in my own kids too. Our son gave up music early in sixth grade, I think. He was an athlete determined focused, hard-working. He was also a good student. Our daughter was an athlete too. But she also was in band and started with the trombone, then switched to percussion in seventh grade. Played all the way through high school. She’s going to graduate for Michigan State in May and hopefully head off to vet school. I’m so glad she had music. The band connected her throughout her high school years and the music wired her brain for learning. Have a wonderful weekend and keep making your days count.

        Like

  17. I just tried to leave a comment but it wouldn’t let me. I am so deeply sorry for the loss of your special and obviously impactful friend. Sending many (((hugs)))

    Like

  18. Oh, gosh, now my eyes are leaking. I knew this was where you were leading when I started reading, but you said it so well and wrote a lovely tribute to your director. What a generous thing you did by writing her a Thank-you letter before she passed! Teachers never get enough of those, you know. I hope she’s got her baton arm warmed up and is happily (and healthily) leading band in Heaven now! Please accept my condolences on your loss — and whatever you do, DON’T let your band fall by the wayside. Y’all need each other now more than ever!

    Like

    • It’s been very hard. The next two concerts, the last of this season, will be dedicated to her. The last concert will be filled with her favorite pieces, including one that was commissioned for her when she retired. I don’t know how we’ll get through it.

      Liked by 1 person

  19. A great tribute to your band leader and friend. I am sure her gift to the world of music will continue to play on for quite some time.

    Like

  20. Oh Dawn, this is so beautiful. I’m crying tears for a life well lived and for all the hearts Shelley touched~ those ripples you mentioned will continue for generations.

    I’m so glad your band was together and played on Tuesday. What a powerful way to grieve and celebrate a person at the same time.

    Hugs ❤

    Like

Leave a reply to Dakota/Caren/Cody Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.